Top 10 Car Insurance Companies in Wyoming for 2024

Finding the right car insurance in Wyoming can be a daunting task. With so many companies to choose from, how do you know which one is right for you? Worry not, Wyoming drivers! This blog post will break down the top 10 car insurance companies in the state, highlighting their pros, cons, and average prices.

Best car insurance in Wyoming

If you’re looking for the best car insurance in Wyoming, we recommend comparing quotes from the providers below.

1. USAA car insurance covarage

Pros:

  • Consistently top-rated for customer service (J.D. Power)
  • Highly competitive rates, especially for good drivers and military members
  • Wide range of coverage options and discounts
  • Excellent financial stability

Cons:

  • Not available to everyone – eligibility restricted to military members, veterans, and their families

Average full coverage price: $2,923 per year

2. State Farm Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Strong brand reputation and financial stability
  • Widespread network of agents and local offices
  • Variety of coverage options and discounts
  • Good customer service ratings

Cons:

  • Rates can be higher than some competitors
  • Less flexibility in policy customization compared to some companies

Average full coverage price: $1,267 per year

3. Geico Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Generally the cheapest rates in Wyoming, especially for minimum coverage
  • User-friendly website and mobile app for easy quotes and management
  • Wide range of discounts available

Cons:

  • Customer service reviews can be mixed
  • Limited agent representation in some areas
  • May not offer as many coverage options or discounts as other companies

Average full coverage price: $1,977 per year

4. Allstate Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Strong brand reputation and financial stability
  • Wide range of coverage options and add-ons
  • Relatively competitive rates for full coverage
  • Good customer service ratings

Cons:

  • Rates can be higher than some competitors for minimum coverage
  • Limited availability of discounts compared to some companies

Average full coverage price: $1,918 per year

Cheap car insurance in Wyoming

If you’re looking for the cheap car insurance in Wyoming, we recommend comparing quotes from the providers below.

5. Farmers Insurance Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Competitive rates for full coverage, especially for certain demographics
  • Strong local presence and agent network
  • Variety of coverage options and discounts
  • Good customer service ratings

Cons:

  • Rates for minimum coverage can be higher than some competitors
  • Website and mobile app not as user-friendly as some companies

Average full coverage price: $1,151 per year

6. American National P&C Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Generally cheaper rates for drivers with less-than-perfect driving records
  • Wide range of coverage options and add-ons
  • Available in most states

Cons:

  • Not as well-known as some competitors
  • Customer service reviews can be mixed
  • Limited availability of discounts

Average full coverage price: Varies depending on driving record

7. Progressive Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Known for innovative and unique coverage options
  • Competitive rates for certain demographics
  • User-friendly website and mobile app
  • Variety of discounts available

Cons:

  • Rates can be higher for some drivers, especially young drivers
  • Customer service reviews can be mixed
  • Not as widely available as some competitors

Average full coverage price: Varies depending on driver profile

8. PEMCO Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Strong regional presence in the Northwest
  • Competitive rates for good drivers
  • Good customer service ratings
  • Variety of discounts available

Cons:

  • Not available nationwide
  • Limited coverage options compared to some competitors

Average full coverage price: Varies depending on location and driver profile

9. The Hartford Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Strong financial stability and reputation
  • Wide range of coverage options and add-ons
  • Good customer service ratings

Cons:

  • Rates can be higher than some competitors
  • Not as widely available as some companies

Average full coverage price: Varies depending on driver profile

10. Auto-Owners Insurance Car Insurance Coverage

Pros:

  • Mutual company owned by policyholders, potentially leading to lower rates
  • Strong regional presence in the Midwest
  • Good customer service ratings
  • Variety of discounts available

Cons:

  • Not available nationwide
  • Limited coverage options compared to some competitors

Compare car insurance in Wyoming

RankCompany NameWebsiteProsConsAverage Full Coverage Price
1USAAusaa.com: https://www.usaa.com/Consistently top-rated customer service, highly competitive rates, wide range of coverage options and discounts, excellent financial stabilityNot available to everyone – eligibility restricted to military members, veterans, and their families$2,923 per year
2State Farmstatefarm.com: https://www.statefarm.com/Strong brand reputation, widespread network of agents, variety of coverage options and discounts, good customer service ratingsRates can be higher than some competitors, less flexibility in policy customization$1,267 per year
3Geicogeico.com: https://www.geico.com/account/Generally the cheapest rates in Wyoming, user-friendly website and mobile app, wide range of discountsCustomer service reviews can be mixed, limited agent representation, may not offer as many coverage options$1,977 per year
4Allstateallstate.com: https://www.allstate.com/Strong brand reputation, wide range of coverage options and add-ons, relatively competitive rates, good customer service ratingsRates can be higher for minimum coverage, limited availability of discounts$1,918 per year
5Farmers Insurancefarmers.com: https://www.farmers.com/contact-us/Competitive rates for full coverage, strong local presence, variety of coverage options and discounts, good customer service ratingsRates for minimum coverage can be higher, website and app not as user-friendly$1,151 per year
6American National P&Camericannational.com: https://www.americannational.com/wps/portalCheaper rates for drivers with less-than-perfect records, wide range of coverage optionsNot as well-known, mixed customer service reviews, limited discountsVaries depending on driving record
7Progressiveprogressive.com: https://www.progressive.com/manage-policy/Innovative and unique coverage options, competitive rates for certain demographics, user-friendly website and app, variety of discountsRates can be higher for some drivers, mixed customer service reviews, not as widely availableVaries depending on driver profile
8PEMCO Insurancepemco.com: https://pemco.com/autoStrong regional presence in Northwest, competitive rates for good drivers, good customer service ratings, variety of discountsNot available nationwide, limited coverage optionsVaries depending on location and driver profile
9The Hartfordthehartford.com: https://www.thehartford.com/Strong financial stability, wide range of coverage options and add-ons, good customer service ratingsRates can be higher than some competitors, not as widely availableVaries depending on driver profile
10Auto-Owners Insuranceauto-owners.com: https://www.auto-owners.com/Mutual company (potentially lower rates), strong regional presence, good customer service ratings, variety of discountsNot available nationwide, limited coverage optionsVaries depending on location and driver profile

Remember:

  • These are just average prices. Your actual rate will vary depending on your individual driving record, car, location, and coverage options.
  • It’s important to compare quotes from multiple companies before making a decision.

Additional Tips:

  • Consider your driving needs and budget when choosing coverage options.
  • Read the fine print of any policy before you buy it.
  • Ask questions and get clarification from any insurance company you’re considering.

I hope this comprehensive list of Wyoming’s top 10 car insurance companies, along with their pros, cons, and average prices, helps you find the best coverage for your needs. Drive safe!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the minimum car insurance requirement in Wyoming?

A: Wyoming requires drivers to have at least liability insurance, which covers bodily injury and property damage to others in an accident you cause.

Q: What factors affect car insurance rates in Wyoming?

A: Several factors affect rates, including your driving record, age, car model, location, coverage options, and credit score.

Q: How can I get the best car insurance rates in Wyoming?

A: The best way to get the best rates is to compare quotes from multiple companies. You can also try to improve your driving record, maintain a good credit score, and consider bundling your car insurance with other policies like homeowners or renters insurance.

Q: What are some discounts that car insurance companies offer in Wyoming?

A: Common discounts include bundling discounts, good student discounts, safe driver discounts, and discounts for having certain safety features in your car.

Q: What should I do if I’m in a car accident in Wyoming?

A: If you’re in an accident, you should immediately exchange information with the other driver(s) involved, report the accident to the police, and file a claim with your insurance company.

Q: How can I file a complaint against a car insurance company in Wyoming?

A: You can file a complaint with the Wyoming Department of Insurance by calling 307-777-7401 or visiting their website at https://doi.wyo.gov/.

Leave a comment